A pillar weatherseal feedback

[French_elans]

Hello everybody,

would anyone have some experience of A pilar weatherseal sold by SJ Sport cars, PNM or lotus classic parts.
(B100V0117F and B100V0118F)
Is there a difference between them ?
Is it as original, in open cell foam or could we hope a closed cell foam improvement ?

link to parts :
SJ : https://www.sjsportscars.com/parts-and- ... V0117F.htm
PNM : https://www.pnmparts.co.uk/index.php?ro ... B100V0117F
Lotus classic parts : https://www.parts.classicteamlotus.co.u ... 3159-p.asp

thank you in advance for your answers.

regards