Porting the wastegate

Moderators: theelanman, dapinky, Specky, clemo, Nige, Sy V, Dave Eds, DaveT, Elanlover, muley, Enright, algirdas, nitroman, GeoffSmith

Postby Enright » Sat 29.12.2007, 15:34

OK, possibly a bit of progress.
Geoff, I've sent you an email - please confirm receipt.
Striking fear into the hearts of duplicate posts everywhere...! :P

BCingU,
Neil ;-)
User avatar
Enright
Modificator
 
Posts: 4860
Joined: Sun 19.12.2004, 19:21
Location: Arnold, Nottingham, England

Postby GeoffSmith » Sat 29.12.2007, 15:57

Confirmed - off to the garage!
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

Postby Russc » Sat 29.12.2007, 19:55

Mines still fairly in bits as i haven`t had time to put it back together. I fyou need any piccies shout.

I didn`t bother with a guide as it didn`t exactly do it by the manual.
User avatar
Russc
Fanatic
 
Posts: 502
Joined: Thu 02.03.2006, 14:51
Location: North/Kent SE/London

Postby GeoffSmith » Sat 29.12.2007, 20:00

I'm a bit stuffed with the O2 sensor at the minute! :evil:
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

Postby Enright » Sat 29.12.2007, 20:38

Seems as though they only expect them to come out when they're already shagged.
Striking fear into the hearts of duplicate posts everywhere...! :P

BCingU,
Neil ;-)
User avatar
Enright
Modificator
 
Posts: 4860
Joined: Sun 19.12.2004, 19:21
Location: Arnold, Nottingham, England

Postby GeoffSmith » Mon 31.12.2007, 01:10

Paul/Neil/Russ,

Our local B&Q is showing low stock of the Bosch grinding stones - what is the OD of the conical wheel please?

Geoff
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

Postby Enright » Mon 31.12.2007, 01:43

20mm (now I KNOW I put that in my article - sorry - email!)
Striking fear into the hearts of duplicate posts everywhere...! :P

BCingU,
Neil ;-)
User avatar
Enright
Modificator
 
Posts: 4860
Joined: Sun 19.12.2004, 19:21
Location: Arnold, Nottingham, England

Postby GeoffSmith » Mon 31.12.2007, 08:17

Enright wrote:20mm (now I KNOW I put that in my article - sorry - email!)


So you did. :oops:
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

Postby drasicjazz » Wed 06.02.2008, 08:03

hi i m looking into getting me the 2.1/4 peco
and i will probebly port my wastegate stait away aswell
as it 's look very logic to me with a bigger exhaust
but what would be a good diameter
i did hear 20 , 21 even 22
can you drill the hole to big?? let's say 25

and in that case would you suffer from a less accurate bypassvalve that
can almost start to flutter ==

see to my opinion the bigger the hole the more accurate the actuator has to control the bypassvalve


making sence here???
User avatar
drasicjazz
Enthusiast
 
Posts: 122
Joined: Wed 30.01.2008, 09:30
Location: Belgium, Kortrijk

Postby rip » Wed 06.02.2008, 10:25

I should be porting my own wastegate next week while my cylinder head is off, so I am only going on pics etc (& memory because Enright showed me the offending wastegate on a turbo at Stoneleigh in November).

The wastegate has a lip at the valve seat which reduces the diameter from 20mm to around 16mm or less. This is the cause of the problem, so needs to drill it away until the pipe is straight at the seat.

Geoff has just ported his own wastegate so will probably be able to describe it in graphic detail :D
1990 SE
User avatar
rip
God
 
Posts: 5905
Joined: Sun 08.04.2007, 07:48
Location: Milton Keynes, UK

Postby paulwatkins » Wed 06.02.2008, 10:33

rip wrote:Geoff has just ported his own wastegate so will probably be able to describe it in graphic detail :D


Theres some pics on page 2 of this thread HERE
User avatar
paulwatkins
God
 
Posts: 1431
Joined: Thu 13.04.2006, 08:54
Location: WsM, UK

Postby Enright » Wed 06.02.2008, 13:34

drasicjazz wrote:hi i m looking into getting me the 2.1/4 peco
and i will probebly port my wastegate stait away aswell
as it 's look very logic to me with a bigger exhaust
but what would be a good diameter
i did hear 20 , 21 even 22
can you drill the hole to big?? let's say 25

and in that case would you suffer from a less accurate bypassvalve that
can almost start to flutter ==

see to my opinion the bigger the hole the more accurate the actuator has to control the bypassvalve


making sence here???

The wastegate hole diameter is marginal - which could explain why some cars overboost while others don't.
Increasing the hole diameter by 5mm from 16 to 21mm is over a 33% increase, which is plenty.
The flap which covers the wastegate hole is only about 25mm diameter. A 25mm flap covering a 21mm hole leaves only a 2mm width of seal.
You don't want any less of a seal than that or it might leak, which wouldn't be good.
The reason we went to 20-21mm was simply that we found an off-the-shelf grindstone which was perfect for the job. Don't go any bigger.
Striking fear into the hearts of duplicate posts everywhere...! :P

BCingU,
Neil ;-)
User avatar
Enright
Modificator
 
Posts: 4860
Joined: Sun 19.12.2004, 19:21
Location: Arnold, Nottingham, England

Postby drasicjazz » Thu 07.02.2008, 04:44

thanks for that
i realy think this is a very interessting topic

so here is an other question is you don't mind
what is the result if you port your wastegate to let say 20 -21
is you have the standard exhaust( no chip no nothing-- everything standard)

see what i want to know--- and maybe i m going way overboard --- :smt030 here
is why would they have a original hole of about 16 if there was enough material to have a bigger hole? with would give a bigger range of exhaust diameter

would it be to have a good seal over the hole?????

OR would it be for the sencetivity of the valve (actuator)...

see if you actuator initially start to open the valve with 16 diameter or (let's go extreem) a 100 (if we woudn't be limited ) than with your 100 you would OVERPORT (my new term :wink: )

and send a signal back to the actuator to close the port
and so could start a flutter....

as i see it; when open a wastegate with a valve rotating form 0°
to 90° ; the biggest change in opening of the wastegate is between 0° and 15° SEE GRAPH :shock:


NOW have a look at this the origional waste gate has a full travel of the actuator available to regulate an opening of 16mm

the new - wastegate (21mm) has only 12-13% (11°)of the actuator travel available to regulate this 16 mm opening

so this would give a much more fragile system in the lower boost or original boost zone

and as i think would cause a flutter (fast increase and decrease of the valve opening) , specially in the lower boost area
:smt112

all this may or may not be true ( proof me wrong :wink: )
or is just insignificant small

but if ...if
......
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
drasicjazz
Enthusiast
 
Posts: 122
Joined: Wed 30.01.2008, 09:30
Location: Belgium, Kortrijk

Postby GeoffSmith » Thu 07.02.2008, 09:05

:agree:

The wastegate is in the feedback loop of a closed loop system. By changing the 'gain' of the device by increasing (or even reducing) the diameter, we are also affecting the time dependent characteristics of the device: referencing your curves, the angle taken to increase the effective diameter by a set amount changes, therefore the time to induce this change must also change.

The ECU and ancillary devices are also part of this loop and the ECU will have been programmed to operate with all devices' characteristics (within a range of tolerances) so that the boost may be controlled over the desired range. The ideal situation in such a closed loop system is to have the system critically damped, which means that the output will be regulated as close to the desived value as possible as fast as possible. If, for example, the turbo did not spool up as fast as intended, the system would be slower (than the ideal) to respond and is classified as overdamped, however, if the wastegate was slower to respond, the system would become underdamped and inherently unstable.

By increasing the diameter of the exhaust, we are increasing the gain (and time element) of the turbo by decreasing the pressure on the exhaust side and therefore increasing the pressure across the turbo. With the existing wastegate, the turbo cannot be controlled but by trial and error (or one trial and no errors so far!) we have found a size which can control the turbo - it may not be the optimum but it works, it is easy to do and it does not take the size of the wastegate near the limits (diameter of the flap).

Taken to the limit, increasing the size of the wastegate orifice to the size of a dustbin lid would undoubtedly introduce instability as the ECU would command the wastegate to change by say 1°, yet this would bypass the turbo completely and all boost would be lost; the ECU would then compensate by changing the wastegate by -2° which would completely shut it, resulting in the turbo producing too much boost ....... etc. etc.

It was inevitable that the ECU was designed to be slightly underdamped so that minor changes in devices would not result in instability. I would imagine that the exact diameter of the wastegate could not be calculated accurately during design, so some margin was included in the casting to allow for minor adjustments of the diameter if necessary (thankfully!).

Geoff
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

Postby drasicjazz » Thu 07.02.2008, 09:53

brilliant geoff!!!

engisch is not my native so i was stuggeling a bit but i'm hapy that somebody worded out what i was saying and i couldn't say it any better
i love it

you're the man!

this is fun. :-D
User avatar
drasicjazz
Enthusiast
 
Posts: 122
Joined: Wed 30.01.2008, 09:30
Location: Belgium, Kortrijk

Postby rip » Thu 07.02.2008, 10:23

Drastic,

I understand your theory here and agree with it.

I am also interested to here what function you used to create your graph. Would changing the y-axis to the square of the diameter give a better indication of how much effect you are having by opening the port? Maybe 20mm is not the optimum. Calculating it like you have done must surely be better than trial and error?

(& I understand your postings perfectly without having to read them twice, so your English is just fine.)

Jack.
1990 SE
User avatar
rip
God
 
Posts: 5905
Joined: Sun 08.04.2007, 07:48
Location: Milton Keynes, UK

Postby drasicjazz » Thu 07.02.2008, 12:42

thanks jack
but

sorry to say but my graph was more like a poor estimation.
i could probably do beter i just don't have the tool for it
no calculations were used to create the graph :?
anyway i m sure that the graph would be a limit function where infinity would be 90° :shock:
and exponetional decreasing towards the full opening

it would be a challange to create a us formula that could simulate
exhaust diameter/volume versus wastegate diameter/volume
a good tool to use for this would be MATLAP a system diagnostic tool
for complex systems
anyway i would like to give it a shot .... just for fun... and maybe to find us a ideaal/minium opening for the wastegate at a given exhaust diameter
to prevent us from overboost

wouldn't that be an achievement :wink:

LIKE WE HAVE NOTHING ELSE TO DO... :smt117

the thing is I just started to look at the elan systems so i'm way underknowledged at this stage specially compared to other lec'ers
wauw i'm impressed!!!

:smt038

ta
Bruno
User avatar
drasicjazz
Enthusiast
 
Posts: 122
Joined: Wed 30.01.2008, 09:30
Location: Belgium, Kortrijk

Postby rip » Thu 07.02.2008, 13:55

Infinity=90 & closed = 0 degrees: that would be the tangent function, except that airflow is not that simple.
Ideally this would involve lots of experimentation. Unfortunately, this is impractical because the turbo is such a pain to access in the first place.

Oh well, best go with the flow (pun intended) and just open out to 20-21mm.

Jack.
1990 SE
User avatar
rip
God
 
Posts: 5905
Joined: Sun 08.04.2007, 07:48
Location: Milton Keynes, UK

Postby AndyH » Thu 07.02.2008, 16:54

My head hurts :bonk:

I just posted in the exhaust thread my intention to do this job tomorrow... but I may wait until you clever people have come up with the definative diameter before doing it.... having said that I may as well get the thing off at least :D
User avatar
AndyH
Enthusiast
 
Posts: 103
Joined: Mon 08.09.2003, 17:15
Location: Fairford

Postby GeoffSmith » Thu 07.02.2008, 17:50

Another one for the WPC (Wastegate Porting Club). :lol:

I've told Iain/Rip/Jack/Schizo that I am looking to getting made up a set of stainless wastegate manifold to turbo studs (four studs with three different lengths) and nuts for £19.70 (£22.81 + delivery from SJ's) which will probably be of interest as some of yours will break! :cry:

I'm also trying to source 9 off stainless manifold to cylinder head serrated and flanged nuts - best price at the moment is £17.82 (£6.13 + delivery from SJ's) but they are as rocking horse droppings.

Deeaitch is helping to put together a set of stainless fasteners for things like the turbo covers.
Calypso Red S2 #417

USB ElanScan interfaces - £60 incl. UK P&P & £65 incl. ROW P&P
User avatar
GeoffSmith
Kitty Fiddler
 
Posts: 15628
Joined: Fri 03.02.2006, 21:57
Location: S2#417 in Tytherington, Gloucestershire

PreviousNext

Return to Turbos, Boost, and Intakes

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest