by dapinky » Tue 16.05.2023, 09:19
There are many schools of thought on this, and all of them are 'right' for certain circumstances.
First, although you say there is little evidence of grease leaking, it is important to know that any cut or split will empty the boot over time, as the grease is actually oil when assembled at the factory.... thick oil (or maybe it is thin grease???) admittedly, but certainly runny enough to escape over a period of inactivity and leave the internals protected at stand-still, but not good for driving.
As such, only you can decide if there is likely to be any damage to the internals..... and I suspect that the only way to tell is to remove them for inspection.
The good news is that it is quite possible to do the inner boots without removing the shaft from the gearbox (although it will be easier if you do - and if you send them away for reconditioning, they'll have to come out anyway) - I have just got the boots to do mine, and it is scheduled for this afternoon. By removing the big metal securing band on the boot, the whole outer shaft assembly will slide out of the 'tulip' (obviously, you need to remove the outer shaft from the hub first!).
The inner bit of the joint is a simple tripoid mechanism, which is an 'off the shelf' part with the part number GKN MS3H002 (it has a 1" diameter with 30 splines) and is held to the shaft with a single circlip. This is the part which will be worn (if anything is worn) and is a simple remove circlip, slide unit off shaft, remove old boot, put on new boot, fit new tripoid, replace circlip add grease, refit driveshaft to car, slide boot into correct place, add new clips...... and it probably took longer for you to read that than it takes to do the job!
However, if there is a possibility that the tulip is rusted/worn/damaged then I would suggest sending it away to be inspected/machined/repaired and then get the whole lot balanced.
As with anything, early repair is quite simple, but if it gets left until it is far worse, then it may need a specialist (and we all tend to leave stuff until it is too late, it's just the way things are!).